Strong Rare Watches Sale on Halloween 2026 in Monaco

The trip to the live auction of Monaco Legend Group this Halloween weekend was definitely worthwhile. Even if there were no real big surprises, the bidding can be described as emotional on occasions. The catalog was overall strong, but it did not feature very spectacular lots as the previous ones did.

Strong Results Behind Solid Offer
€ 22.3 m total sales were achieved, against 26.6 m this spring and 28.6 a year ago. Despite the monetary decline, the auction was a success, given all lots were sold (‘White Glove Sale’). The top tickets achieved high hammer prices as did some rare Cartiers too.
Million Euro Lot Number 50: John Goldberger’s Rolex 6062
The top lots did well. The important Patek Philippe lots 234 (Ref. 2499) and lot 181, a perpetual calendar and minute repeater sold over a million. So did the Rolex Oyster Perpetual with triple date and moon phases indication from lot 50 too. At € 1.86 m, the watch stayed within its taxation. However, the estimate was ambitious for the piece. It was in a nice condition and came with a proven provenance but the combination of gold-colored hands and hour markers with the silver-colored steel case is not the most desired one. In addition, the replacement of the luminous markers left dark halos around them.

Rare Audemars Piguet and Vacheron Constantin
The undoubtedly most important watch in the sale was the Audemars Piguet in lot 208. It was made at a time, when not even Patek Philippe offered calendar wristwatches and it was sold at almost € 730 m, over 80% above its higher estimate. The Vacheron Constantin ‘Cioccolatone’ from lot 30 might not have been as important but it was big and ‘size matters’, especially when talking vintage. The watch went for almost half a million at € 494 m. Another one is coming up at Phillips this weekend and it seems to be in a better condition still!

Noble Nautilus
The rare Jumbo Nautilus in white gold from lot 40 remained within its lower range, while the Tiffany steel watch in lot 227 did surprisingly well. It surpassed its higher estimate of € 260 k with a strong overall price of € 442 k. Likewise, the hammer price of the automatic perpetual calendar ref. 3940 from lot 215 was high at € 481 k and significantly above its taxation of up to € 300 k.

Cartier on a Roll
Especially Cartier was strongly represented in the sale and the brand accounted for the most surprises too. Again, provenance played an important role. Prices for rare Cartiers went up so much that errors start to cost. John Goldberger aka Auro Montanari stands for authenticity and quality. That’s why it is not surprising that many of the most successful lots came from his collection. The energy in the room was strong, however I did not see him there.

Master Watchmakers Andersen and Roth
At MLG, vintage is king, so that there were few lots of independent watchmakers in the catalogue. Still, lots 128 and 62 did well, indicating the strength of the genre. Lot 63 was a perpetual calendar by Andersen Genève that sold at € 104 k, 3.5 times its higher estimate. Lot 128 was a beautiful golden chronograph by Daniel Roth from the 90’s. It too beat its estimate of € 60.000 by a almost 90%!

Valuable Perpetual Calendar by Breguet
The strong result of lot 128 is a good segway into lot 23, as the perpetual calendar from Breguet stems from the times that Daniel Roth was still the chief watchmaker there. The piece from the 1980’s was sold at € 86 k, hence almost three times its higher estimate.

Universal Genéve Enamel
There were more strong results, like for example the Universal Genève with cloisonné dial, that beat its estimate behind € 91.000 significantly, by over € 30.0000.

Very Glossy Gilt Dials
The Rolex chronographs with their ‘gilt’ dials in lots 73 and 151 also achieved remarkable results given it seemed clear that none of the two watches had originally been conceived with the dials that were mounted on them. In addition, while the case of the ref. 6034 was strong, the silhouette of the ‘Pre Oyster’ reference 3330 was less than sharp. Still, they both sold at high prices. The beautiful Vacheron chronograph from lot 149 would have done great too for sure, unfortunately the watch was withdrawn in the seventh hour.

The giant leap as perhaps anticipated did not occur and that was not to be expected given the Audemars Piguet in lot 208 was the only timepiece of importance beyond personal collections in the sale. But still, some of the results achieved and the energy during the auction hinted at the latent strength of the market. That might unfold next weekend in Geneva. I will report!
Herzliche Grüße aus dem bunt - herbstlichen - Taunus,
Oliver Knop



